Alfie. Cilla Black. 1966. Parlophone.
Romance is a theater of heightened expectations, a stylized game of co-conspirators in which reality is often referred to, but only inasmuch as it advances a fantasy of selves. The object of romance isn’t love itself, but its simulacrum; the fantasy that when life turns its glum and silent face to us, we’ll outrun it and never surrender to boredom. The songwriter who most clearly understood the sound of post-war America’s infatuation with pop romanticism, capturing its moods and textures, was Burt Bacharach. His songwriting talent was to wed ersatz sophistication to accessible song forms, a combination that made the experience of heartbreak feel so contemporary, so modern, it still recalls those cartoon Roy Lichtenstein ingenues in startling color and Ben-day dotted emotional torment. He also relocated a song’s point of tension from overt sentiment to that perfect moment when romance tips into eroticism. Where most songwriters from previous generations went in search of the timel...